Luke Fahey vs. Tavien St. Clair: Who Will Start for Ohio State Against USC?

Copyright: © 2026 Adam Cairns/The Columbus Dispatch/USA TODAY Network
Copyright: © 2026 Adam Cairns/The Columbus Dispatch/USA TODAY Network

Ryan Day weighs Luke Fahey and Tavien St. Clair for Ohio State’s starting QB job as the Buckeyes prepare to face USC on Saturday.

Ohio State’s quarterback situation is the biggest question facing the Buckeyes as they prepare to travel to Los Angeles for Saturday’s matchup with USC. Julian Sayin remains out indefinitely with a throwing-arm injury, leaving true freshman Luke Fahey and sophomore Tavien St. Clair competing for the starting job.

Ryan Day has not announced a starter. However, his comments Tuesday gave insight into where the competition stands. Fahey entered last week ahead of St. Clair, but both quarterbacks still have a chance to earn the job in practice.

“Going into the last few games, Luke’s been ahead of Tavien, in terms of what we’ve seen. That’s why he went in first,” Day said. “But both guys are working hard.”

Ohio State needs to settle on a quarterback who can manage the offense against a talented USC team at the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum. Day said the staff will evaluate the competition throughout the week, with each practice rep carrying added importance.

Luke Fahey Holds the Edge in Ohio State’s QB Battle

Fahey entered the Indiana game as Ohio State’s backup, ahead of St. Clair on the depth chart. When Sayin suffered his injury against the Hoosiers, Fahey was the first quarterback off the bench.

The freshman has completed 9 of 13 passes for 203 yards, two touchdowns and two interceptions this season. His most productive outing came against Kent State, when he completed four of five passes for 141 yards and a touchdown.

Fahey arrived at Ohio State from Mission Viejo, California, where he threw for more than 7,000 yards and 68 touchdowns during his high school career. 247Sports rated him a three-star recruit.

His limited college experience remains a factor, but Fahey has already earned the coaching staff’s trust as the first option behind Sayin. Day’s comments suggest that advantage carried into the USC preparation, though the competition remains open.

Tavien St. Clair Closing the Gap?

St. Clair brings a different physical profile to the competition. The 6-foot-4, 235-pound quarterback from Bellefontaine, Ohio, was a five-star recruit and ranked No. 3 quarterback in the nation by 247Sports. He has completed five of seven passes for 52 yards and a touchdown this season. St. Clair also appeared in one game as a freshman in 2025.

Day said St. Clair has responded to the situation with renewed focus and needs to prepare as though he will start. The coaching staff has taught both quarterbacks the offense, but Day acknowledged that the game plan may need to emphasize each player’s strengths.

“Most of what they’re doing will be for the first time,” Day said of the young quarterbacks. He stressed the need to find the right balance between protecting the football and remaining aggressive.

Day also confirmed that playing both quarterbacks remains possible, depending on how the game unfolds.

Ryan Day Wants Toughness and Command of the Offense

Day identified toughness as his top priority for the quarterback who takes the field. He said the position requires physical, mental, and emotional toughness, particularly when the player is facing a challenging road environment with limited experience.

The Buckeyes need their quarterback to handle routine plays, stay on schedule, and avoid turning difficult situations into bigger problems. Day doesn’t want the offense to get overly conservative, but he also knows careless decisions could give USC chances to take control.

“You can’t overthink it,” Day said when discussing the adjustment to game speed. “You just got to find the speed of the game and trust your training.”

Ohio State’s offense has averaged 39.3 points and 476.3 yards per game this season. Those numbers reflect the production built around Sayin, and the staff must determine how much of that approach translates to either backup quarterback.

The challenge is especially pressing against USC, which enters the game following a 24-7 loss to Wisconsin. The Badgers recorded five sacks and intercepted two passes in that matchup.

Ohio State’s Offensive Line Must Support Its Young Quarterback

Carson Hinzman emphasized that the offensive line has a responsibility to make the transition easier for whichever quarterback starts. That includes clear communication, handling protection responsibilities, and helping the quarterback play with confidence.

Hinzman said both Fahey and St. Clair have shown confidence and an understanding of the offense. He also stressed the importance of taking ownership of the position once the game begins.

“Once you’re out there, you’re not a freshman at Ohio State, you are the quarterback of Ohio State,” Hinzman said.

Ohio State could also lean more heavily on its running backs. Day said Bo Jackson, Isaiah West, and Legend Bey must run downhill and play physically, giving the offense another way to stay on schedule as the quarterback adjusts to a bigger role. Making that approach will help reduce the burden on either young passer.

When Will Ohio State Name Its Starting Quarterback?

Day said the coaching staff will continue evaluating both quarterbacks in practice before deciding who gives Ohio State the best chance to win. He acknowledged that one player needs more first-team reps as the week progresses, making the next few practices critical.

Fahey currently holds the advantage because he was ahead of St. Clair entering the Indiana game and received the first opportunity after Sayin’s injury. St. Clair, however, remains in contention, and Day has not ruled out using both players.

Ohio State faces a difficult road test against a USC team looking to respond after its loss at Wisconsin as its season goals hang in the balance. The Buckeyes need a quarterback who can command the huddle, protect the football, and execute the game plan under pressure.

The competition is still open, but for now, Fahey has the inside track, while St. Clair has an opportunity to change the conversation before Saturday’s kickoff.


Discover more from The Silver Bulletin

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

This article has 1 Comment

  1. I think we will see primarily Fahey as he primary. But I won’t be surprised if St. Clair shows up for short yardage / goal-to-goal situations. Maybe even some wildcat with Bay sprinkled in.

Comments are closed.