
The 2026 Ohio State Buckeyes still have room to grow in order to become true National Championship contenders. Here’s what needs to be fixed.
With October waiting on the doorstep, the regular season is now one-third of the way complete. Ohio State is back in the top five of the AP poll, with a month of data to evaluate. Here is what deserves the most attention on the path to a potential playoff run.
Consistent Pass Rush & Run Defense
Rightfully so, the pass rush woes have been well documented this year. Aside from Kenyatta Jackson and Khary Wilder in his limited snaps, the individual efforts haven’t been up to par for an Ohio State defense. As a unit, the body of work so far has been pedestrian at best, and plenty of opportunities have come up for guys to step up. With Wilder consistently getting pressure and recognition from the coaching staff, look for him to play a bigger role as conference play intensifies.
When asked about Wilder and defensive end production, Ryan Day said, “We need production…We’re taking all applications.”
Additionally, Kenyatta hasn’t quite played to his potential, given the competition he faced this year aside from Texas. In fact, he’s started to regress after receiving just a 56.7 pass rush grade from Pro Football Focus against Illinois and ranking 21st overall out of 24 defenders in that game. This grade can certainly be taken with a grain of salt, as opposing lines can key in on Kenyatta with shifts and double teams, but he is also the leader and anchor of that line. If anyone can make an impact weekly, it should be Kenyatta.
Jackson called Ohio State’s rushing defensive performance “unacceptable” during his Tuesday availability. He also noted that giving up 200 rushing yards to Illinois was “terrible,” and that the coaches got on them on Sunday and that the issues are “fixed.”
Playing Young Linebackers More
The linebacker room has been more promising so far. Matt Patricia has even used his backers to generate pass rush at times and has been fairly successful, as Riley Pettijohn himself had a pair of sacks and 4.0 tackles for loss in September. Christian Alliegro and Payton Pierce have also lined up on the edge but haven’t produced much there.
As far as true linebacker roles, Pierce, Alliegro, Pettijohn, and TJ Alford have rotated regularly. From both a film and grades standpoint, Pettijohn and Alford have stood out as their reps have increased. Alliegro isn’t far behind but doesn’t quite have the speed or coverage ability of the younger linebackers.
At times, Pettijohn has been out of position or a tick slower in diagnosing plays. For example, against Illinois, he had edge run responsibility on a play in the second half. However, because of poor positioning and awareness, Illinois RB Jordan Anderson went untouched for a 22-yard touchdown run and briefly got Illinois back into the game. Something like this could carry greater consequences down the road.
This is all part of the learning experience for a young linebacker, though. It’s better for inexperienced guys like Pettijohn and Alford to have grown through this first month, which, for the most part, they have. Moving forward, Alford and Pettijohn profile as the backer combination that will make the Silver Bullets most dynamic. If the defensive line can generate pressure on its own without LB help and give these younger, athletic guys a chance to make plays behind them, then this defense reaches its full potential.
Building Wide Receiver Production Outside Jeremiah Smith
It can’t be overstated how talented and generational Jeremiah Smith is. But what separates the junior phenom is his mindset and discipline, according to Day. The attention Smith draws from opposing defenses is second to none in college football. This kind of gravitational pull on one player should open up opportunities for other playmakers to step up. So far this year, however, that hasn’t been the case.
Devin McCuin and Brandon Inniss have combined for 298 yards so far this season. To put that into perspective, Jeremiah Smith has 617 yards on 33 catches. Devin McCuin has the second most receptions with 13. This starts to paint the picture of how dependent OSU’s offense has become on Jeremiah Smith. Yes, he is a phenomenal athlete and one of the greatest to ever don the scarlet and gray, but this kind of volume for one player won’t be sustainable as the schedule gets tougher.
Against Texas, the Buckeyes had plenty of success in the first half with Jeremiah. When the Longhorns adjusted at half to take him away, Ohio State’s offense, of course, sputtered and only managed 3 total points in the second half. The point is that teams with relatively equal personnel and coaching (i.e., Indiana, Oregon, USC, Michigan, etc.) will have a blueprint against OSU. As long as they can commit to neutralizing Jeremiah, they know that other receivers likely won’t be able to take full advantage of their matchups.
Brock Boyd and Chris Henry have both flashed in multiple games so far. Day and the staff have shown confidence in these wide receivers to make an impact. If McCuin and Inniss can’t step up when their number is called, I imagine there will be little hesitation to give the young Bucks a shot.
Offensive Line Chemistry
After last season, the offensive line has been squarely under the microscope. With all but one starter returning, the veterans needed to improve noticeably. Thus far, the line has been steady for the most part. The issue lies in second-level blocking and a lack of chemistry because personnel has been shifted around so often.
Austin Siereveld has played three different positions already this year. Gabe Van Sickle has been in and out at right guard but has also been challenging Phil Daniels for playing time. With the right side of the line still a bit of a mystery, it makes you wonder about their true confidence level. As a result, the line hasn’t gelled as a unit. The PFF grades have been above average for the most part, but not where they should be given the competition so far and the defensive lines they still have to face this year.
If Ohio State wants to get where they need to go, Ryan Day and the staff need to commit to five guys that they can stick to and let build chemistry for the next eight-plus games. With that, the line should improve steadily as a unit and, ideally, open up the second level so the running backs can accelerate through for bigger runs. Something that has been missing, but that could change the offense’s entire dynamic and keep pressure off a passing game that already shoulders a lot of it.
As the Buckeyes prepare for maybe the most challenging eight-game stretch in program history, their urgency is at an all-time high. The victory against Illinois had plenty of positives, but it also revealed just how much of this team is still a work in progress. With a trip to Kinnick on the horizon, we’re about to find out just how ready this team is to take the next step to becoming a true championship contender.
Grant Kincaid was born in Columbus, Ohio, and raised in Dayton. He serves as Creative Director and basketball contributor at The Silver Bulletin. At one point, Grant, a collegiate baseball player, also holds a B.A. in Management and Leadership Studies. Aside from the Buckeyes, he is an avid supporter of both the Cincinnati Reds and Bengals. His favorite Buckeyes include Braxton Miller, AJ Hawk, and Ted Ginn Jr.
Discover more from The Silver Bulletin
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.